18 Secrets to Successful Amazon Online Arbitrage

Last updated: July 25 , 2023

Amazon online arbitrage has emerged as a lucrative business model for entrepreneurs looking to harness the power of e-commerce. In simple terms, online arbitrage involves sourcing products from one platform, typically at a lower selling price, and reselling them on Amazon for a profit.

This innovative approach eliminates the need for physical stores, allowing a wide range of Amazon sellers to tap into the site’s vast customer base. With millions of potential customers and an extensive global reach, Amazon provides an unparalleled opportunity for sellers to generate substantial profits.

According to Statista, Amazon was responsible for 50% of ecommerce spending in the US during 2021. While this presents a lucrative opportunity, standing out is also a challenge.

This guide will provide you with valuable insights and secrets to thrive in this highly profitable venture. By implementing the strategies and tips discussed here, you can unlock the potential for unparalleled success in the online arbitrage business.

From product research and selection to streamlined order fulfillment, each aspect plays a crucial role in maximizing profits. Let’s delve into eighteen secrets that Amazon online arbitrage sellers user to stay ahead in the market.

Whether you’re a seasoned seller looking to enhance your online arbitrage business model or a newcomer aiming to break into this world, these tips will give you a solid foundation for success.

Is Online Arbitrage Legal?

Firstly, let's clear the air. If you're wondering, "Is online arbitrage allowed?" then you're in luck. It's completely legal! Any Amazon seller can get started with tactical arbitrage, allowing them to sell on Amazon and make money without having to produce their own products. It often involves signing up for Amazon FBA to utilize Amazon's warehouse services, which allows you to sell on Amazon without worrying about product storage and fulfillment.

Learn more about online arbitrage through FBA here, or start selling online with our expert advice below. 

Product Research and Selection

Achieving success on Amazon requires a lot of thought and research. First, you need to identify the ideal type of products to sell before delving into profitable subcategories. There are lots of factors at play, including the risk of investing in slow-moving or seasonal inventory.

Here are some critical aspects of effective product research and selection.

1. Identifying Niche Markets and Trends

One of the primary secrets to running a successful online arbitrage business is identifying niche markets and leveraging seasonal trends. You can tap into untapped markets with reduced competition by targeting specific product categories or customer segments. 

For example, Home and Kitchen is the top-selling category on Amazon. Instead of attempting to cater to this enormous audience, drop shippers can sell to a niche segment of homeware buyers, such as stay-at-home moms who love cooking but have no formal training.

Keeping a pulse on current market trends is crucial. After choosing a niche, make sure you stay updated on emerging product categories and capitalize on the latest trends. 

2. Using Tools to Find Profitable Products

One of the online arbitrage pros is that you don't need to drive between brick-and-mortar stores searching for products. Instead, you can trawl online retailers from the comfort of your own home.

You can check out regular online retail stores or visit warehouse-style retailers. An online marketplace like Alibaba is a great place to start for new online arbitrage sellers so that you can see the types of products on offer.

Several online arbitrage tools are available to help you find profitable products. Amazon Best Sellers Rank is a valuable resource available for free through the Amazon site. Each category has an organized list of best-selling items, allowing you to see what the customer demands are.

Keepa is another tool at your disposal. It tracks historical pricing and sales rank data for Amazon products. By using Keepa, you can gain insights into price fluctuations, track current sales rank and trends, and identify products with consistent demand. This information enables you to make informed decisions about products and pricing.

Source: keepa.com

3. Identifying Replenishable Items

Identifying replenishable items is a crucial strategy for long-term success in online arbitrage. You should definitely try to incorporate them into your business model.

These are items with consistent demand that you can source repeatedly, replenishing the stock. Replenishable items can provide you with a steady stream of income. Look at things like the product's sales history and if there is continuous availability from suppliers.

Replenishable items often include:

  • Subscriptions
  • Consumables
  • Frequently purchased items
  • Disposable items

Competitive Pricing and Profit Margins

Competitive pricing is a critical factor in attracting customers. While you need to set prices high enough to make a profit, you must also set them low enough to draw customers away from the competition. It’s a balancing act that might take you a while to master.

However, it’s crucial to learn the ropes. Maintaining a healthy profit margin is vital for the long-term sustainability and growth of your business. Here are some strategies for setting the best-selling price.

4. Analyzing the Competition

Firstly, take a look at what your competitors are doing. Monitor the prices of similar products on Amazon (you can do this manually or with software), and study how your competitors position themselves in the market. Take note of their pricing strategies, discounts, and promotions.

Utilizing repricer tools can be immensely helpful in staying competitive. These free tools automatically adjust your prices based on market conditions, ensuring you remain competitive without spending all your time watching prices. That said, you must regularly review your settings to align with your business goals.

5. Repricing Correctly in Europe

If you use Amazon FBA to sell in multiple locations around the world, there are some unique challenges to be aware of. Amazon’s European Fulfillment Network (EFN) can do the job of dropshipping for you. It opens up a new market, which is excellent, but note that the Amazon fees are higher for these sales.

Consider factors like currency exchange rates and market conditions, too. If you plan on running a global arbitrage business, the payoff can be worth it, but it’s much more work.

Want Access To Our Exclusive Arbitrage Sourcing List?

Join thousands of other sellers getting exclusive deals and training to build their Amazon FBA business. Join the VIP List Today!

Online Arbitrage Sourcing

Finding reliable and profitable inventory is a crucial aspect of Amazon online arbitrage. Various sourcing methods are available, each with its own benefits and challenges. If you master a strategy for sourcing, you’re better equipped to run the rest of your business.

6. Finding Suppliers and Wholesalers

One method of sourcing inventory is through suppliers and wholesalers. These sources are ideal for providing you with replenishable items on a consistent basis.

There are multiple ways to find suppliers, including:

  • Online searches
  • Trade shows and industry events
  • Contacting sellers you see at online retailers like Alibaba, Facebook marketplace, and Liquidation.com
  • Speaking with sellers at physical retail stores when you encounter products you like.

Ultimately, the onus is on you to reach out to potential suppliers and be proactive.

7. Negotiating Wisely

When dealing with suppliers, negotiating skills are essential. You can negotiate for better pricing terms, volume discounts, or favorable shipping costs to enhance your profit margins.

Establishing mutually beneficial relationships with suppliers can go a long way for your business. While you can try to haggle on the price, it’s crucial to maintain a positive relationship so that your suppliers stick around.

8. Evaluating Product Quality

As an Amazon FBA seller, ensuring the products you source meet certain quality standards is important. If not, customers can leave negative reviews and tarnish your business’s reputation.

There are multiple ways to evaluate quality. When working with a supplier, you can get a sample of the product yourself (which is also ideal for creating unique promotional materials). However, when using deals sites, you can check product reviews elsewhere online.

9. Using Software to Find Profitable Deals

Leveraging software tools can significantly aid in finding profitable deals. For example, Honey is a browser extension many FBA sellers use to search for coupon codes and deals automatically. It will automatically find deals and apply the coupon code to snag discounts. As a result, you can find the cheapest items available and increase your profit margin down the line.

If you want the best deals, you must diversify your sourcing channels. Relying on just one sourcing method can expose you to risks such as limited inventory or increased competition. So, try a few different methods, like online clearance sales, wholesale suppliers, and retail arbitrage.

You don't want to limit yourself to the same websites, so try to purchase products from a few different places.

Effective Listing Optimization

Optimizing your product listings is essential if you want to increase visibility, attract potential customers, and improve conversion rates. A well-optimized listing increases your chances of appearing in relevant search results and entices customers to choose your product.

There are some key elements of optimizing your listings. Here are some factors to consider.

10. Setting Up Your Amazon Seller Account Correctly

Before selling, you must ensure your Amazon account is set up correctly. Make sure you have chosen the correct seller type, provided accurate business information, and enrolled in programs like Amazon Brand Registry if applicable.

You should also consider establishing an Amazon storefront to advertise the products in your online store. Huge brands have their own Amazon Storefronts, including Reebok, Godiva, and Peloton. These companies spend time creating attractive storefronts to showcase their products.

Plus, having an Amazon Storefront allows you to implement new Amazon ads, including banner ads, potentially boosting traffic.

11. Optimizing Product Listings

An optimized product listing consists of several vital elements. Follow these steps to create a killer Amazon listing:

  1. Compelling title: Write a title that accurately captures the product and includes relevant keywords. Incorporate unique selling points and essential product information to grab attention, but don’t make it too long.
  2. Keyword-rich description: Provide comprehensive details about the product’s features, benefits, and usage. Incorporate relevant keywords naturally throughout the description.
  3. High-quality images: Have you ever purchased a product with zero images? Probably not, right? You must include high-quality, well-lit product images, preferably from multiple angles. Ensure the background is clean and the product is easily visible.
  4. Bullet points: Add bullet points to the description to summarize key information, highlighting unique features and benefits. Make the information scannable.

In terms of keywords, you can use third-party Amazon keyword research tools to identify high-performing keywords. Crucially, you want to select keywords that don’t have too much competition but still have a relatively high search volume.

Source: amazon.com

12. Encourage Reviews

Customer reviews are invaluable on Amazon. 95% of shoppers read reviews before they buy products online, and with such a crowded online marketplace on Amazon, you need positive reviews to stand out.

You can encourage customers to leave reviews by providing high-quality products and excellent customer service. This means addressing issues or concerns promptly. You can also set up automated emails to encourage customers to leave reviews a few days after purchasing.

Streamlined Order Fulfillment

Efficient order fulfillment is a must. On Amazon, many customers are accustomed to Prime's next-day delivery. In fact, there are over 200 million Prime users worldwide. To meet (and exceed) expectations, you need to manage your inventory, label products accurately, and utilize streamlined processes.

13. Using Fulfilled by Amazon (FBA)

Amazon’s FBA service offers numerous benefits for online arbitrage. When you opt for FBA, Amazon handles the entire fulfillment process on your behalf. This includes storage, picking, packing, shipping, and customer service. They conduct everything in-house in an Amazon fulfillment center, reducing your storage costs (aside from the Amazon fees).

The advantages of FBA include fast and reliable shipping, cheaper shipping costs, access to Amazon Prime, and improved customer trust. In other words, leveraging this service can save you time, reduce operational complexities, and provide a top-notch customer experience.

Labeling products correctly is crucial for efficient order fulfillment. Amazon has guidelines for product labeling to help you with accurate identification, so you should use these even if you don’t opt for FBA.

Want Access To Our Exclusive Arbitrage Sourcing List?

Join thousands of other sellers getting exclusive deals and training to build their Amazon FBA business. Join the VIP List Today!

14. Keeping Track of Inventory

Accurate inventory management is crucial for smooth order fulfillment. Regularly monitor your stock levels to ensure you have sufficient inventory. Otherwise, you risk disappointing your customers when things are unavailable. 

There are tons of inventory management software tools out there, including InventoryLab. These tools will track and update inventory in real time. Plus, using AI, many of these tools can generate data and forecasts to help you identify the most profitable stock items.

Amazon’s own inventory performance index (IPI) can help FBA sellers stay on top of their stock levels, too.

Source: amazon.com

Continuous Learning and Adaptation

E-commerce is an ever-changing business, so continuous adaptation is crucial for long-term success. You need to stay updated on industry trends, conduct frequent competitor analyses, and stay on top of Amazon policy updates.

Here are some ways to stay ahead of the curve and take your business to new heights. 

15. Monitoring Account Health

Keep a close eye on metrics such as sale volume, order defect rate, late shipment rate, and customer feedback. You can view these in your Amazon individual seller account. Address any issues promptly to maintain a healthy account and avoid potential penalties or restrictions.

Monitoring your business is one of the most important roles you have as an Amazon seller. Ensure you set aside enough time in your schedule to track these metrics and see where your business is at.

You will also need to stay informed about Amazon’s latest policies and changes that occur in your niche. These changes may affect your account health. You can stay informed by: 

  • Joining online arbitrage communities like online forums and social media groups, connecting you with like-minded Amazon sellers. People in these groups share insights and explain their experiences, which can give you helpful tips.
  • Attend webinars and virtual events hosted by industry experts and successful online arbitrage sellers. These platforms provide valuable knowledge and update you on the latest trends and strategies.
  • Follow influential online Amazon FBA sellers, thought leaders, and industry publications on social media. Or subscribe to their newsletters. Their insights and expertise can provide valuable guidance and keep you informed about industry developments. 

16. Reconciling Your Purchases

Accurate accounting and reconciling your purchases are crucial for managing your Amazon business’s finances effectively. Keep meticulous records of your purchases and expenses alongside your sales. You can perform an accurate profit calculation in a simple spreadsheet, but there are also plenty of high-quality tools at your disposal. These more advanced tools are better for generating data.

Make sure you regularly assess your inventory and proactively manage slow-moving or unsold stock. You can do this by adjusting prices, running promotions, or exploring liquidation options.

17. Scaling Your Business

As your online arbitrage business grows, consider strategies for scaling operations. One option is to hire a virtual assistant (VA) to assist with tasks like product research and sourcing. Delegating certain responsibilities will become crucial as your business grows, allowing you to focus on high-value activities.

By regularly monitoring and assessing your business, you can implement actionable growth strategies. 

18. Enjoy the Journey!

While navigating the complex, fast-paced world of online arbitrage work, enjoying the journey is essential. You should embrace the learning process, recognizing that experimentation and adaptation are integral to success. Stay open to trying new strategies, exploring different methods, and embracing innovation.

Ultimately, online arbitrage is a great way to earn income through Amazon. However, you won’t start making seven figures immediately. Rather than being disappointed, take time to enjoy the journey and the process of building something from scratch.

The Ultimate Strategy Checklist for Online Arbitrage

The secrets and tips shared in this article can revolutionize your approach to online arbitrage and pave the way for success. Let’s recap the key takeaways:

  • Thorough product research and selection are fundamental to success. Identify niche markets, leverage trends, and use software tools to find profitable online arbitrage products.
  • Competitive pricing and healthy profit margins are crucial. Analyze the competition, utilize repricing tools, and set prices strategically to attract more customers and maximize profitability.
  • Diversify your inventory sources and explore methods like retail arbitrage, online clearance sales, and wholesale suppliers to mitigate risks and maximize opportunities.
  • Optimize your Amazon listings to boost visibility and conversion rates. Craft compelling titles, keyword-rich descriptions, and use high-quality images.
  • Prioritize customer reviews and feedback to increase the reputation of your online store.
  • Streamline your order fulfillment processes, ensuring customer satisfaction and minimizing errors. Consider using Amazon’s FBA service to automate the process.
  • Embrace continuous learning and flexibility. Stay informed about industry trends, Amazon policy, and what your competitors are doing.

By implementing these strategies, you can unlock the potential for unparalleled success in the online arbitrage business. Now is the time to take action.

Ready to Revolutionize Your Amazon FBA Business?

OA Cheddar is your trusted partner in navigating the complexities of online arbitrage. With access to bi-weekly webinars from seven-figure resellers and high-quality lead lists that help you maximize your profits, you gain access to a treasure trove of online arbitrage secrets. 

Whether you want to start selling online or grow your existing business as an online arbitrage seller, OACheddar makes online arbitrage easy.

Sign up for OA Cheddar today and unlock the secrets to achieving unparalleled success in Amazon Online Arbitrage.


Join the OA Cheddar VIP List!

  • Exclusive Invites to Training Webinars - Don't miss out on our biweekly training calls. Invites are emailed out for each live call
  •  Stay in Touch - Be the first to hear about our latest offerings  before they sell out
  • Exclusive Deals - You will be the first to know when we run sales or exclusive promos that you can only get by being on our VIP list.

We respect your privacy and will not send spam. Users can unsubscribe at any time.